Everton Stun Man Utd 1-0 at Old Trafford as Gueye Red Card Backfires

It wasn't supposed to end like this. On a cold Monday night at Old Trafford, Manchester United — battered by injuries, frustrated by inconsistency — were handed a crushing 1-0 defeat by Everton, a team that hadn’t won there in over a decade. The final whistle blew at 90'+5 minutes, sealing a result that sent shockwaves through the Premier League and left Manchester United fans staring at their screens in disbelief. The twist? Everton did it with 10 men after Idrissa Gana Gueye was sent off in the 10th minute for slapping teammate Michael Keane — an astonishing, uncharacteristic outburst that should’ve crippled their chances. Instead, it lit a fire under them.

Red Card That Should’ve Killed Them — But Didn’t

The match barely had time to settle before chaos erupted. Just 10 minutes in, Idrissa Gana Gueye, Everton’s midfield enforcer, swung his arm and struck Keane across the face during a heated exchange near the halfway line. Referee Anthony Taylor didn’t hesitate. Red card. No warning. No second chance. The stadium gasped. Even David Moyes, Everton’s manager and former United stalwart, looked stunned. "It was a moment of madness," Moyes admitted post-match. "But the lads didn’t fold. They dug in. That’s character." What followed was one of the most defiant performances in recent Premier League history. With 10 men, Everton sat deep, absorbed pressure, and struck on the counter. Goalkeeper Jordan Pickford was magnificent — making five crucial saves, including a fingertip stop on a Bruno Fernandes free-kick in the 58th minute. "He didn’t just keep us in it," said Everton captain James Tarkowski. "He kept us alive."

The Winner: A Surprising Hero

The goal came in the 88th minute — a moment few saw coming. Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall, Everton’s 24-year-old central midfielder, picked up the ball just inside the United half after a poor clearance. He drove forward, drew two defenders, and curled a left-footed shot past André Onana into the top corner. The ball kissed the crossbar before nestling in. The away end erupted. The home crowd fell silent. It was Dewsbury-Hall’s first Premier League goal of the season — and his first ever at Old Trafford. "I’ve dreamed of scoring here," he said afterward, still breathless. "But not like this. Not with 10 men. Not against them." The goal was the culmination of a tactical masterclass by Moyes. With Gueye gone, Everton abandoned possession and turned into a disciplined, compact unit. They allowed United 68% of the ball — and still won. "We knew they’d dominate," Moyes said. "Our job was to be ruthless when they gave us the ball. We did that."

Historic Win, Historic Context

This was only Everton’s second Premier League victory at Old Trafford in 33 attempts — the first since 2016. For David Moyes, who managed United for nearly a decade, it was deeply personal. He’d lost 12 of his 13 previous league games at Old Trafford since leaving in 2013 — a cruel irony for a man once beloved by the Red Devils. "I’ve got love for this club," he said quietly. "But tonight? Tonight was for Everton." The result also had massive implications for the table. Both teams entered the match with 18 points — tied for sixth alongside Tottenham Hotspur. Everton leapfrogged United on goal difference, moving into fifth. United, meanwhile, dropped to seventh — and now trail the top four by six points with just 13 games left.

What’s Next for Both Clubs?

For Manchester United, the questions pile up. Manager Ruben Amorim has seen his side win just once in their last five home matches. Their next fixture? A home clash with Crystal Palace on Sunday, November 30, 2025, at 12:00 GMT, broadcast on TNT Sports 1 and TNT Sports Ultimate. A loss there could send them into the relegation zone. Everton, meanwhile, will look to build on this momentum. Their next Premier League match is away to Leicester City on December 1, 2025. But the real test? A home game against Manchester City on December 14 — a match that could define their season.

The Bigger Picture

This match wasn’t just about three points. It was about identity. United, for all their money and history, continue to look directionless. Everton, despite financial constraints and years of instability, showed grit, organization, and belief. And in Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall and Jordan Pickford, they have emerging stars who can carry them forward. The Premier League thrives on these moments — where underdogs defy logic, where mistakes become motivation, and where history is rewritten in 90 minutes. This was one of those nights.

Frequently Asked Questions